Key Takeaways:
- Inspect annually — small problems become structural failures within 2–3 seasons
- Repair vs rebuild decision typically hinges on joist + ledger condition, not the deck surface
- Common repairs: board replacement ($150–$500), railing fix ($300–$1,500), ledger reseal ($800–$2,500), joist replacement ($1,500–$5,000)
- Rebuild makes sense if more than 30% of structural members are compromised — usually cheaper long-term
- We provide a written inspection report before any repair work begins
Repair Types and Costs
1. Surface board replacement
Cracked, splintered, or rotted top boards. Common on pressure-treated decks 8+ years old.
Cost: $150–$500 for a few boards; $1,000–$3,000 for full surface replacement.
2. Railing repair
Loose posts, broken pickets, separated rail caps.
Cost: $300–$1,500 depending on extent.
3. Stair repair
Loose stringers, cracked treads, separated risers. Often the highest-priority safety issue.
Cost: $400–$1,800.
4. Ledger reseal
The most critical structural repair. Water has gotten behind the ledger and rotted the rim joist or the house framing. We:
- Remove decking near the ledger
- Pull the ledger
- Inspect rim joist and house framing for rot
- Replace any rotted lumber
- Install proper Z-flashing + house wrap repair
- Reseat ledger with through-bolts (not lag screws)
Cost: $800–$2,500 if the rim joist is sound; $2,500–$6,000+ if rim joist replacement needed.
5. Joist replacement
Individual rotted joists. Usually rim joist or end joists touching ground.
Cost: $1,500–$5,000 depending on number of joists.
6. Footing remediation
Heaved footings (frost damage) or sunken footings (poor original install). May involve lifting the deck, replacing the footing, and resetting.
Cost: $2,000–$6,000+.
7. Full structural rebuild
Frame stays the same footprint, all framing replaced, new decking, new railing.
Cost: $40–$80/sq ft — half to two-thirds of a new deck.
When to Repair vs Rebuild
| Condition | Repair | Rebuild |
|---|---|---|
| Surface boards rotted, frame OK | ✓ | |
| Railing failing, frame OK | ✓ | |
| 1–2 joists rotted | ✓ | |
| 3+ joists rotted OR rim joist rotted | ✓ | |
| Ledger rotted into house framing | ✓ | |
| Footings heaved | depends | depends |
| Deck under-engineered for current code | ✓ | |
| Deck over 20 years old, multiple issues | ✓ |
The math: if repair cost approaches 50%+ of replacement cost, rebuild is the better long-term decision. You get a 25–50 year warranty starting fresh, and the repair lifespan is typically 5–10 years before more issues emerge.
Inspection Process
Our inspection ($150 fee, credited toward repair work):
- Surface walkthrough — boards, railing, stairs
- Underdeck probe — joist condition, fastener pull-out, rot detection with awl
- Ledger inspection — flashing, fastener type, water staining behind
- Footing check — level, plumb posts, frost damage
- Code compliance — railing height, baluster spacing, stair geometry
- Written report with photos and recommended action
Common Issues by Deck Age
| Age | Most likely issue |
|---|---|
| 5–8 yrs | Surface board fade/stain failure, loose railing pickets |
| 8–12 yrs | Stair stringer cracks, ledger water staining starts |
| 12–18 yrs | Joist end rot, rim joist concerns, footing heave |
| 18+ yrs | Rebuild typically more economical than repair |
What to Do Right Now
If you notice any of:
- Spongy spots when walking
- Visible rot or soft wood (probe with screwdriver)
- Gap between deck and house at the ledger
- Sloped or sinking corner
- Loose railing post you can move by hand
Schedule an inspection. These don't self-resolve.
Request a deck inspection or repair or, if your deck is past saving, see our composite decking options for a clean rebuild.
See also: deck resurfacing • composite rebuild options
